This essay sketches the psychological biography of the modern nation state in india in the early years of the nationalist movement. Nandy joined the centre for the study of developing societies csds, delhi, as a young faculty member. Can indias patriotism be built on accepting differences. Ashis nandys the intimate enemy a critique over the last 150 years the impact of the west on eastern societies has been felt through political, cultural and economical domination. I find this gandhi difficult to gulp and so would have, i believe, gandhi himself.
He has also offered alternative conceptions relating to. Ashis nandy might seem an unlikely candidate for such an accusation. Ashis nandy, the illegitimacy of nationalism, new delhi. This ideology makes little sense to most indians, who have their own religious and cultural lives, their own diverse pasts, and their own. Rabindranath tagore and the politics of self new delhi. This paper deals with the work of ashis nandy, one of the main contemporary indian. Rabindranath tagore and the politics of self oxford india paperbacks book online at best prices in india on. This is a thought provoking critique of the national movements surface nationalism and is full of insight into how ambiguous and variegated the nationalism of the independence movement really was. See on this theme, ashis nandy, the illegitimacy of nationalism. Lies, lies, and utter lies of ashis nandy swarajya. The illegitimacy of nationalism 1994 edition open library.
Oct 18, 2016 indians have a different kind of territoriality, a sense of belonging which is built more on oldstyle patriotism. An evaluation by abhijit sen, aditya mukherjee, amar farooqui, anil choudhry, apoorvanand, ashish nandy, atul. Pdf the illegitimacy of nationalism semantic scholar. Most nationalist leaders in india, adopting uncritically the western ideology of nationalism, were then. Hazing and honor at the philippine military academy. To a lot of people, it will seem an inner contradiction, as if tagore did not know his mind because there are thousands of people who went to jail or marched in.
The dominance is derived from the links the idea of history has established with the modern nationstate. This demands a patriotism premised on an inclusive love of all our peoples, a commitment to their integral welfare, and faith in an idea of india with its multicultural, plurireligious society as less a nation state than a multinationstate in the making. But many people find only this gandhi tolerable and live happily with him. Alternative sciences, the illegitimacy of nationalism, the savage freud by ashis nandy pp. Over the barricades of indian nationalism in raja raos short.
Ashis nandy and the cultural politics of selfhood pdf. The first gandhi is the gandhi of the indian state and indian nationalism. Indians have a different kind of territoriality, a sense of belonging which is built more on oldstyle patriotism. The biography and political career of this official gandhi began early. Merryl wyn davies, ashis nandy, and ziauddin sardar. Ashis nandy, one of indias foremost public intellectuals, contends in this book that indias political and cultural elites have been trying to impose a secular ideology on their country. How do you address tagores concept of nationalism which seems contradictory to many people. Indian nationalism and religious identity guided history. This ideology makes little sense to most indians, who have their own religious and cultural lives, their own diverse pasts, and their own principles of tolerance and hospitality. This is a collection of three significant works of ashis nandy alternative sciences, the illegitimacy of nationalism, and the savage freud. Ashis nandy explains how nationalism can be restrictive on business standard. Negative emotions and intellectual prejudice can be powerful mass mobilisers against powerless scapegoats but they are always very bad counsellors.
Historys forgotten doubles northern arizona university. Includes bibliographical references filmographies introduction. Nandy has also coauthored a number of human rights reports and is active in movements for peace, alternative sciences and technologies, and cultural survival. Neither a celebratory retrospective nor elegiac souvenir on the occasion of his 80th birthday, the festschrift is actually a primal. A trained clinical psychologist, nandy has provided theoretical critiques of european colonialism, development, modernity, secularism, hindutva, science, technology, nuclearism, cosmopolitanism, and utopia. A read is counted each time someone views a publication summary such as the title, abstract, and list of authors, clicks on a figure, or views or downloads the fulltext. Indian popular cinema as a slums eye view of politics ashis nandy dilip kumar made me do it ziauddin sardar raj kapoor. Meanwhile, he was invited by a number of universities and research institutions abroad to carry out research and to give them lectures. Rabindranath tagore and the politics of self oxford india paperbacks. Ashis nandy is currently an indian council for social science research icssr national fellow associated with the centre for the study of developing societies, delhi.
Nationalism is an ideology and is configured in human personality the way other ideologies are. Sahapedia an open online resource on the arts, cultures and. People didnt have the moral sanction to kill even during the partition if the bjp regime lasts long enough, sizeable sections of the bureaucracy, army. Apr 16, 2010 the conclusion considers how tagore could celebrate the mothernation in his imaginative literature, and at the same time be a committed opponent of nationalism. Sahapedia an open online resource on the arts, cultures.
Heidelberg papers in south asian and comparative politics the. To a lot of people, it will seem an inner contradiction, as if tagore did not know his mind because there are thousands of. In this book, one of indias some might say, of the worlds most eminent intellectuals sets out to examine the antinationalist thinking of a dissenter among dissenters, the nobel prizewinning. Ashis nandy and the postcolonial trap butterflies and wheels. Nandy, a political psychologist and social theorist whose pathbreaking work has revitalized scholarship on political psychology, the indian encounter with colonialism, mass violence, nationalism and culture, was the featured speaker at the sarah kailath lecture here. Saha, sanskrit for together with, is an invitation to explore together the richness of our cultural landscapes. In fact, this kind of stand of tagore, according to nandy, created some sort of confusion among most of the indian nationalists of the time for whom nationalism, patriotism and antiimperialism.
Even in europe, before the 19 th century there was nothing called nationalism. Breaking with the tradition, ashis nandy explores the ways in which colonialism damaged the colonizing societies themselves, and how the likes of gandhi resisted their rulers in british india by building on the lifestyle, values, and psychology of ordinary indians and by. Over the barricades of indian nationalism in raja raos. For a detailed and insightful look at upadhyay, see julius lipner, life and thought. Political, economic, and cultural domination under colonialism has repeatedly been studied during the last hundred years. Ashis nandys interests have embraced scientific creativity, future studies, postdevelopmental and postsecular visions, cities. Sahapedia is a nonprofit organisation registered in india under the societies registration act of 1860. Neither a celebratory retrospective nor elegiac souvenir on the occasion of his 80th birthday, the festschrift is. He is a political activist and a major commentator on contemporary affairs, known for his championing of nonviolence and tolerance.
He posited critiques to prove how secularism is as an ideology has failed to attain what it uttered or still utters about the peaceful coexistence of religions. Nationalism is an ideology and is configured in human personality the way other ideologies. Ashis nandy is a fellow and director of the centre for the study of developing societies, delhi. Ashis nandy 1994 distinguishes all such nationalism from a patriotism founded on humanism and universalism. Ashish nandy apologises for article on gujarat 2007 polls in sc. Sahapedias mission to creatively engage with culture and history to reveal. Seductions and perils of nationalism iium journals. Every government since independence has been uncomfortable with it. It rode piggyback into the afroasian world in colonial. One of foreign policys top 100 public intellectuals, he has written about communal violence, particularly hindumuslim riots and the. There was patriotism, people fought and died for king and country, they. Heidelberg papers in south asian and comparative politics. Ashis nandy author of the intimate enemy goodreads.
Nationalism and regionalism in south asia home sau. Nationalism is based on lectures delivered by him during the first world war. There are many avatars of nationalism premised on very different understandings of the idea of india. Ashis nandy is a prolific political psychologist, sociologist, and cultural critic. Ashis nandy and the vicissitudes of the self international. Nationalism, genuine and spurious a very late obituary of two early postnationalist strains in india ashis nandy abstract nationalism is not patriotism.
Most nationalist leaders in india, adopting uncritically the western ideology of nationalism, were then convinced that the absence of a proper nation state and proper nationalist sentiments were major lacunae in indian society and indices of its backwardness. He is a member of the executive councils of the world future studies federation, the commonwealth human rights initiative, the international network for cultural alternatives to. Analysis of rabindranath tagores views on nationalism in. I move away from chatterji to focus on ashis nandy, i will be arguing that that conceptual tie may, for reasons that are broadly philosophical, be undeliverable. In fact, as pointed out by ashis nandy, tagore although rejected the idea of nationalism but professed antiimperialist politics throughout his life. While working there, he developed his own methodology by integrating clinical psychology and sociology. The massive carnages at rwanda and bosnia have taught the students of genocide that the most venomous, brutal killings and atrocities take place when the two communities involved are not distant strangers, but close to each other culturally and socially, and when their lives intersect at many points. Sahapedia is an open online resource on the arts, cultures and heritage of india. He has been awarded the grand prize of the fukuoka asian culture prizes 2007.
Tagore and nationalism download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi. Ashis nandy s interests have embraced scientific creativity, future studies, postdevelopmental and postsecular visions, cities. Rabindranath tagore and the politics of self oxford india paperbacks nandy, ashis on. Historys forgotten doubles ashis nandy abstract the historical mode may be the dominant mode of constructing the past in most parts of the globe but it is certainly not the most popular mode of doing so.
Ashis nandy, an indian secularism analysis expertise critical of secularism in indian subcontinent states. These seminal books on culture, politics, psychology and science have had a wide readership and are available here for the first time within a single volume which includes an introduction by ziauddin. In 2008, nandy was listed as one of the top 100 public. The secret politics of our desires internet archive. While the nations of europe were doing battle, tagore urged his audiences in japan and the united states to eschew political aggressiveness and cultural arrogance. Well, a lot of people look very internally inconsistent.
1628 332 1634 663 914 1355 310 794 1287 527 973 1483 481 238 1405 46 1425 1014 1337 805 1133 262 1203 464 448 697 567 1295 1054 918 460 634 345 340 500 1388 71 1444 449 1495 1461 163 300 904 1023 920